I mean, once again, the reason why this argument continue is this supposed left-wing takeover of the Biden WH to actual lefties does not seem like a left-wing but instead the actual give 'n take of coalitional politics and just continues to convince lefties and progressives that the centrists will see anything short of 100% control of the party by centrist Establishment types as too far left.
One day we'll take to heart that normal people see no difference between think tanks, consultants, advocates and lobbyists. We are all considered the so-called DC consultant class. We are all the groups.
Think tanks like Searchlight are in the same business as consultants: giving Dems bad advice on how to win elections.
Searchlight and a bunch of similar orgs (Welcome, Third Way etc) aren’t policy think tanks, they are “here is how we win” think tanks. The public is correct to conflate these people with consultants, even if they are technically distinct.
It's hilarious that the people waxing on about insulated, out of touch consultants are the same ones who will harp on and on about using the importance of using the word "genocide" when discussing Israel-Gaza.
The author states, "[m]ore broadly, the theory doesn’t account for one of the biggest problems in Democratic politics over the last decade, which is that a variety of left-wing advocacy organizations and their campaign advisors issued polling and election analysis that misled the party about what voters actually want." Wow. Now that is one big fat generalization without any actual cited documentation. Somebody's a wee bit sensitive about the left. Yes, the left is too extreme on some issues, but I have never seen so many people who are fed up with establishment candidates (on both sides) who pander to big money influencers of one sort or another. Lest we forget, there is more than a cogent argument to be made that the DNC's centrist and establishment wing delayed Biden’s exit, effectively preventing an open primary. Establishment risk aversion and institutional mechanics delayed his exit until Harris was the only option. A prior example was the DNC's overt support and pre-ordained coronation of Hilary Clinton, in lieu of running a true open primary, which Sanders might actually have won, and prevented trump 1.0. So yes, the "left" is demanding change. A "business as usual" approach is not going to work anymore.
The last line sums it all up. You can't enact change without getting elected to office. I say this as someone who is a leftist, progressive, whatever you call it.
This is a crazy blog to write given Searchlight was explicitly created to oppose left wing candidates and ideas.
I guess this sort of essay works on people who don't know that. Not sure what to think about a blogger who targets low-information readers.
"It takes all kinds."
I mean, once again, the reason why this argument continue is this supposed left-wing takeover of the Biden WH to actual lefties does not seem like a left-wing but instead the actual give 'n take of coalitional politics and just continues to convince lefties and progressives that the centrists will see anything short of 100% control of the party by centrist Establishment types as too far left.
DC Consultant class writes essay that the consultants are good, actually
I’m not a consultant!
One day we'll take to heart that normal people see no difference between think tanks, consultants, advocates and lobbyists. We are all considered the so-called DC consultant class. We are all the groups.
Think tanks like Searchlight are in the same business as consultants: giving Dems bad advice on how to win elections.
Searchlight and a bunch of similar orgs (Welcome, Third Way etc) aren’t policy think tanks, they are “here is how we win” think tanks. The public is correct to conflate these people with consultants, even if they are technically distinct.
It's hilarious that the people waxing on about insulated, out of touch consultants are the same ones who will harp on and on about using the importance of using the word "genocide" when discussing Israel-Gaza.
The author states, "[m]ore broadly, the theory doesn’t account for one of the biggest problems in Democratic politics over the last decade, which is that a variety of left-wing advocacy organizations and their campaign advisors issued polling and election analysis that misled the party about what voters actually want." Wow. Now that is one big fat generalization without any actual cited documentation. Somebody's a wee bit sensitive about the left. Yes, the left is too extreme on some issues, but I have never seen so many people who are fed up with establishment candidates (on both sides) who pander to big money influencers of one sort or another. Lest we forget, there is more than a cogent argument to be made that the DNC's centrist and establishment wing delayed Biden’s exit, effectively preventing an open primary. Establishment risk aversion and institutional mechanics delayed his exit until Harris was the only option. A prior example was the DNC's overt support and pre-ordained coronation of Hilary Clinton, in lieu of running a true open primary, which Sanders might actually have won, and prevented trump 1.0. So yes, the "left" is demanding change. A "business as usual" approach is not going to work anymore.
BTW, if you want an answer to the original title of this article, "Is the DC Consultant Class Evil?" (which is how it came thru in my email), then I suggest you see this piece for how the public perceives it: https://www.nytimes.com/2026/10/06/us/politics/trump-advisers-republika-srpska.html.
The last line sums it all up. You can't enact change without getting elected to office. I say this as someone who is a leftist, progressive, whatever you call it.
The DC consultant class can suck dead dogs as far as I’m concerned. Same with the pundit class.
I have to admit I find it odd that so many people who hold such strong opinions work so hard against their own interests.