7 Comments
User's avatar
Kevin Flood's avatar

“Square off with trump next summer “ over the war? Is this author nuts?

Deep Sleeper's avatar

I could not disagree more with the author concerning Schumer. Yes, Schumer is the consummate senate insider and knows where all the bodies are buried. But in a number of ways, Schumer represents what progressives have been opposing for years, and that new vision is exactly why so many progressives got elected and delivered this blue wave. First, there is an undeniable desire—not just among progressives—for new leadership and a different direction. Schumer is an old dog that cannot learn new tricks and therefore not up for the task. Second, and as evidence for the first point, Schumer actively maneuvered against some of the progressive candidates who won: El-Sayed (Michigan) and Flanagan (Minnesota), who won their races despite opposition from establishment leadership (lead by Schumer). In addition, there is a good case that candidates like Angie Nixon in Florida and Jamie Davis in Louisiana narrowly lost because they did not receive enough backing from Schumer's establishment network. Third, progressives have criticized Schumer for opposing efforts to block arms sales to Israel over its conduct in Gaza, and they want new leadership who is willing to use upcoming appropriations votes to immediately cut off war funding rather than agreeing to stopgap measures. In contrast, Van Hollen has campaigned on giving rank-and-file senators a greater voice in how the caucus operates and has explicitly pledged to stay out of contested Democratic primaries. Van Hollen has aligned with progressives on U.S. policy toward Israel and Gaza—including voting to block arms sales to Israel and attempting a fact-finding mission to Gaza—and has joined Sanders in demanding an immediate end to war funding. Van Hollen has framed the leadership race not around ideological labels, but around aggressively confronting "a rigged economy, rigged in favor of the very wealthy and fueled by political corruption," arguing that a 56-seat Democratic majority gives the Senate a generational mandate to pursue major reforms. Exactly what America needs now.

Martha Howell's avatar

We've been putting centrist Dems in place for decades and nothing has changed for us. If you're owned by the Epstein class, your party has little bearing on your vote. The status quo put us in this hole. More of the same will not lift us out of it.

Thersitism's avatar

On the Iran war, it's hard to square your position that Senate Democrats need a plan to end the Iran war with your support for Schumer. Schumer was on the wrong side of the whole Iran issue. He sided with Netanyahu against Obama during the Iran deal. Before Trump attacked Iran, when Trump was ostensibly negotiating. Schumer egged him on with the "No side deals" video.

The Iran war and its effects were such a huge part of the election and we need a leader who is on the right side of the issue. Many will remember how, in 2006, Democrats won a wave election, riding discontent with the Iraq War, and pledged to end the war but, once in power, failed to use their leverage to withhold funding.

Aidanalysis's avatar

This fight might be divisive on Capitol Hill and DC, but it's not divisive with regular Democrat voters, who are sick of Schumer and ready for someone new now.

I appreciate that Schumer was a helpful force this midterms, and yet I'm not convinced that he was responsible for anything extraordinary we saw two weeks ago, or that another leader might not have done most of the same. So why should we wait 2 more years for someone new? We let Biden be a bridge, how'd that go?

Ron Bengtson's avatar

Biden forgot he was a bridge and ran for reelection.

Aidanalysis's avatar

Exactly. No one wants to step down when they should. That's why you have to make them