After pulling off the biggest midterm victory in fifty years, Democrats should be turning their attention to delivering wins. Unsurprisingly, given the factional battles of recent years, they first have to wade through a divisive fight over who should lead them, with Senator Chris Van Hollen challenging Senator Chuck Schumer for the top job.
As someone who served Senate Democratic Leader Harry Reid for seven years, worked closely with Schumer, and has been represented by Van Hollen most of my life, I wanted to offer some thoughts about the path forward.
This race should be about who will unite the caucus, deliver on a bold agenda, and lay the groundwork for a Democratic trifecta in 2028. I’ve had plenty of disagreements with Schumer. But of the two, I think he’s the better man for the job, whereas Van Hollen appears to be running more to promote himself than to serve the best interests of the caucus.
However, in order to meet the understandable demand for generational change, Schumer should take the reins for two more years, then retire and pass the torch to the next generation.
What the Senate Majority Leader actually does
The primary responsibility of the Senate leader is to chart a course that represents the full spectrum of views within the caucus — a tricky job under any circumstances, but one that requires extra finesse when you are leading a big, ideologically diverse group, like the ones Reid oversaw or the one Americans elected two weeks ago.
This is a tall task, since the position has fewer means of control at its disposal than the Speaker of the House. The Speaker position was created by the Constitution and is endowed with near-dictatorial power. The position of Senate leader, by contrast, did not exist until the 1920s, when it was created as a largely secretarial job. Back then, the true masters of the Senate were the committee chairs, and the leader mostly did their bidding.
In the 1950s, Lyndon B. Johnson infused the position with real authority for the first time. But he did so largely through informal means, and much of his power was derived from the fact that his famous arm-twisting and jawboning was backed up by old bulls, such as Richard Russell of Georgia.
As the Senate evolved from a free-flowing body to more of a command-and-control structure, the majority leader became more powerful — an evolution I chronicle in my first book, Kill Switch. Yet even so, the position remains far more reliant on forging consensus and far less able to dictate terms than the Speaker.
In the House, the Rules Committee acts as an extension of the Speaker and sets the terms for every bill that comes to the floor. By contrast, the Senate leader must forge consensus in order to move forward, or clear the 60-vote threshold of cloture (what we now refer to as the filibuster). That means building consensus on legislation and uniting the caucus are the top responsibility of the majority leader. Without that, nothing will get done.
The race for leader
This brings us to the current race for Leader between Van Hollen and Schumer.
My view of the contest is informed by my own complicated history with Schumer. When I worked for Harry Reid, the tension between our staff and Schumer’s was legendary. On one occasion, I was meeting with Reid in his office when Schumer entered the room and demanded I leave. As I stood outside, I could hear Schumer screaming “Fucking JENTLESON” through the closed door. Later, with a bemused smile, Reid told me that Schumer had somehow become convinced I planted a story that cast him in a negative light. (Who can say?)
I have never been one to reflexively defend Schumer, and I am not here to let him off the hook for actions like joining with AIPAC to actively oppose the Iran nuclear agreement — which Reid was able to preserve, despite Schumer’s best efforts.
Yet, more recently, Schumer has evolved in ways that reflect the new ideological direction of his caucus. In 2024, he said Netanyahu was an “obstacle to peace” and called for Israel to hold new elections, a stance AIPAC criticized. While Schumer endorsed the AIPAC-backed Haley Stevens, he was also quick to support Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed once he won the nomination, including investing over $50 million in his race.
This kind of dexterity is what one would expect from a Senate Leader. And it is why I find Van Hollen to be mismatched with the attributes that are necessary to do the job well. Instead of seeking to set the caucus up to unify and succeed together, he is playing off party tensions to win plaudits with factional players.
The job of leader is to be a strategic player — and in some instances a sin-eater for the rest of the caucus — so the other members can shine. Yet since the beginning, Van Hollen’s crusade has been marked by self-promotion. He launched his effort to oust Schumer with a campaign-style video paired with an email acquisition form.
To lead the most ideologically diverse Senate Democratic Caucus we’ve had in decades, a leader needs to give members room to represent the politics and interests of their states. While much ink has been spilled analyzing why Democrats were so successful two weeks ago, it all comes back to one core reason: for the first time in many years, Democrats ran candidates who fit their states and districts, and gave them leeway to do so without imposing the purity tests of the past.
That is enormous progress — so much so that Democrats are now within reach of a supermajority. Part of what has been so encouraging about the past few months is that we seem to be on the verge of moving past many of the internecine fights that have defined the party for the past several years, towards a new approach that some call fusionism and I call heterodoxy.
Yet Van Hollen’s posture suggests that he wants to reverse this trajectory and move back towards a more rigid, factional approach. He has leaned hard into factional dynamics, leveraging intraparty conflict to raise his own profile. The job of a leader is to build consensus, but Van Hollen’s campaign has tacitly accused his colleagues who do not support him of being part of a rigged system.
I personally don’t disagree with Van Hollen on everything. For example, he has said that the DSCC shouldn’t take AIPAC money, a stance that I argued for back in June. I also appreciated his brave decision to fly down to El Salvador and meet with Kilmar Abrego Garcia, one of his constituents who was wrongly deported by the Trump administration.
His supporters seem to think that Van Hollen would be a different kind of leader because he would impose their preferred positions on the caucus. Van Hollen himself has been vague about his intentions. But he can’t have it both ways: if he is not seeking to impose his positions, then how, exactly, will he differ from Schumer as leader — and what is the point of this remarkably divisive fight?
Democrats need a smarter plan to end the Iran War
One area where Van Hollen has articulated a clear difference is his plan to end the war in Iran. The goal is one Democrats broadly share and should pursue aggressively, but Van Hollen’s plan is half-baked and would wrong-foot the caucus.
With government funding set to expire on December 11, Van Hollen has argued that Democrats should filibuster the funding bill as leverage to end the war and force a government-wide shutdown during the holidays, furloughing thousands of government workers who are still recovering from the threat of DOGE, many of whom are Van Hollen’s constituents.
Democrats are broadly united on ending the Iran war. The midterms delivered a mandate to do so, and they should absolutely use their power to force the issue. But Van Hollen’s plan plays to Democrats’ weaknesses, not their strengths.
In a few short weeks, Democrats will take control of both chambers of Congress and be in a much stronger position to force Trump’s hand. Starting in January, Democrats will be able to write the funding bills themselves. They can pass bills to fund the rest of the federal government, and isolate (and withhold) funding for the Iran War. This isn’t a dynamic where the goal is to forge a bipartisan deal, such as BAAJA — this is entirely a leverage play to force Trump and Republicans to do something they do not want to do.
Instead of forcing a government-wide shutdown during the holidays, stranding federal workers without pay and muddying the message, the smart move is to pass a short-term agreement now that funds the government into next year, but expires in the spring or summer, setting up a showdown with Trump over Iran. Democrats will be in control and able to press their case from a position of strength.
The fact that Van Hollen gravitated so quickly to the short-term shutdown strategy demonstrates why I think he is ill-equipped to be leader. Putting the entire caucus on the spot for a game of one-upmanship sows needless division and is antithetical to the job of leader. Already, we are seeing dissent among the caucus about this strategy, with newly elected senator Annie Andrews voicing opposition today.
A bridge to the future
There’s another factor working in Schumer’s favor: the small detail of having overseen Senate Democrats’ most sweeping victory since Watergate.
While Schumer missed on some candidates (of whom I was critical at the time), Democrats ended up winning those seats anyway. Meanwhile, Schumer was responsible for recruiting senators who were probably the only candidates who could win their races, such as Peltola and Turek — or win by huge margins, as was the case with Roy Cooper, freeing up resources to invest heavily in states such as Michigan. Schumer also made the prescient decision to invest resources in Mississippi, helping to elect Scott Colom.
Put all this together, and I think Schumer has a pretty strong case for leader, even as I’m clear-eyed about his faults.
Yet I also understand the impulse from Van Hollen’s supporters to seek new leadership after a change election.
One way to resolve this tension — to bring an end to this divisive race while satisfying the desire for change — is for Schumer to be a bridge to the next generation, and announce that he will retire at the end of his term, which ends in 2028.
Schumer has a chance to do something truly historic: finish what he started by steering Democrats to a supermajority in 2028, and go out on top, with grace — something that is in short supply in politics these days.
I hope he seizes it.



“Square off with trump next summer “ over the war? Is this author nuts?
I could not disagree more with the author concerning Schumer. Yes, Schumer is the consummate senate insider and knows where all the bodies are buried. But in a number of ways, Schumer represents what progressives have been opposing for years, and that new vision is exactly why so many progressives got elected and delivered this blue wave. First, there is an undeniable desire—not just among progressives—for new leadership and a different direction. Schumer is an old dog that cannot learn new tricks and therefore not up for the task. Second, and as evidence for the first point, Schumer actively maneuvered against some of the progressive candidates who won: El-Sayed (Michigan) and Flanagan (Minnesota), who won their races despite opposition from establishment leadership (lead by Schumer). In addition, there is a good case that candidates like Angie Nixon in Florida and Jamie Davis in Louisiana narrowly lost because they did not receive enough backing from Schumer's establishment network. Third, progressives have criticized Schumer for opposing efforts to block arms sales to Israel over its conduct in Gaza, and they want new leadership who is willing to use upcoming appropriations votes to immediately cut off war funding rather than agreeing to stopgap measures. In contrast, Van Hollen has campaigned on giving rank-and-file senators a greater voice in how the caucus operates and has explicitly pledged to stay out of contested Democratic primaries. Van Hollen has aligned with progressives on U.S. policy toward Israel and Gaza—including voting to block arms sales to Israel and attempting a fact-finding mission to Gaza—and has joined Sanders in demanding an immediate end to war funding. Van Hollen has framed the leadership race not around ideological labels, but around aggressively confronting "a rigged economy, rigged in favor of the very wealthy and fueled by political corruption," arguing that a 56-seat Democratic majority gives the Senate a generational mandate to pursue major reforms. Exactly what America needs now.